Following the suggestion of a reader, I re-plotted the worldwide minimum wage vs. unemployment. Before you skip ahead to the chart below, keep in mind the lesson I learned from my last post which was that international economies are vastly different from America’s, and examining the extremes doesn’t translate easily back to American circumstances.
In the last post, I was surprised to find that there were a slew of countries with a minimum wage that was higher than the average wealth (GDP per capita). All of these countries were very poor and were recipients of foreign aid. I speculated that this foreign aid helped support such high relative minimum wages. So, hopefully, the unemployment numbers would be low.
The red bubbles are the top 20 countries for minimum wage/average wealth. As you can see, the minimum wage is set above the average wealth in every single country. The mean unemployment rate was 25%. Looking at the chart, the variability is high, but it looks like unemployment really sky rockets when the minimum wage is set above 1.3x the GDP per capita.
There’s a cluster of countries (Paraguay, Vanatu, Tajikstan and Papua New Guinea) where that appears NOT to be true. Wikipedia articles for these countries showed that the minimum wage might not be enforced.
In fact, the high unemployment in all of these countries seems to be due to other de-stabilizing factors that have nothing to do with the minimum wage. For instance, the state department has this to say about Liberia: “Due to the country’s continued severe economic problems, most citizens were forced to accept any work they could find regardless of wages or working conditions.”
The blue dots show the bottom 20 countries for relative minimum wage. The unemployment in these countries averaged 7.8%. Side note: I was a bit surprised to find Russia among the bottom 20 nations. Furthermore, I was scratching my head to see that Russia gets foreign aid ($983 million, about 1/2 coming from the US).
Take away? Numbers and charts don’t always tell the story!
- Sources for minimum wages: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_minimum_wages_by_country
- My source for the GDP per capita and the unemployment rates came from the in-built datasets in Mathematica. They might be a year or two out of date.
- Information on Paraguay and minimum wage: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Paraguay
- Information on Libera and minimum wage enforcement: http://www.state.gov/j/drl/rls/hrrpt/2010/af/154354.htm